Keep Up: Why upload speeds are the forgotten part of the broadband equation


While most of use are now more than comfortable with operating in a mobile world, even the non- technical understand that a wireless connection is never quite as good as a fixed line. It’s, what I like to call, received wisdom.

Except it’s wrong.

Thanks to EE, I’ve recently made the jump from 3G (so last decade) to LTE, (or 4G as everybody has insisted inaccurately  calling it, though it’s not, but that’s for another day). A quick speed test on my EE-powered iPhone 5 gives me a ping of 53ms, download speeds of 23.02Mbps and and an upload speed of 17.95Mbps. (By way of comparison I turned off LTE on the iPhone and got 49/2.18Mbps/2.65Mbps respectively. Eurgh.).

Last night a similar speed test on my home broadband gave me a ping of 19ms, 29.82Mbps on the download and 2.75Mbps on the upload.

This was on a Virgin Media cable connection that is nominally a 60Mbps connection. At peak times, that download speed is pretty much halved, or sometimes ever more so – the inevitable consequence of when marketing triumphing over sensible capacity planning.

However, it’s still fast enough for me to ‘get by’ if being able to comfortably stream Super HD content from Netflix can be considered getting by. Let’s spare a thought for those who can’t get anywhere near 30Mbps – let alone double or triple that.

However, it’s not the download speed that concerns me – it’s the upload speed that’s of interest. The fact that my mobile phone can now upload at speeds that are six times faster than my fixed line connection is, when you think about it, actually quite remarkable. In fact, with LTE, your mobile handset or dongle connected PC is now better connected than many fixed lines. And that’s important.

As we move ever closer to a cloud-based world we are sending ever more content upwards as well as pulling it down. Uploading a bunch of pictures to Facebook? Emailing a large presentation to a client? Sending video to a server? A 1Gb connection on the downlink won’t help you if your uplink isn’t also up to scratch.

Of course in the UK on fibre connections from incumbent BT or other providers using its network, the standard upload speed is up to 20Mbps. But that’s only in-line with LTE – not faster. You could also argue that many of the uploading tasks that consumers are doing are directly from mobile devices, and that a better upload speed is therefore more necessary on your phone than on your fixed line. But when you consider that cable provider Virgin Media offers an upload speed of just 5 per cent of its download speed on all but its top-tier package, it’s not unreasonable to feel that it’s   short-changing  its customers.

LTE then has thrown down the gauntlet to the fixed-line guys, and it won’t make happy reading for the networks in terms of reducing CAPEX. If they’re going to ‘keep up’, to coin a popular marketing slogan, they’re going to have to upgrade their networks, or face losing customers to the cable free world of LTE.


4 thoughts on “Keep Up: Why upload speeds are the forgotten part of the broadband equation

  1. I tend to get close to the 3Mbps but it’s frustrating that a friend round the corner gets 17Mbps upload on Plusnet, – and the same on my phone. If I ever need to send a large file from home I’d be better off using the Personal Hotspot feature on the iPhone and sending it via that.

  2. It’s a lot easier to get high data rates on your LTE device because the data caps are so severe. How long will you sustain those rates when you’ve exceeded your monthly cap?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s